quinta-feira, 22 de fevereiro de 2018

"Remembering the White Rose"


Seventy-five years ago Thursday, a group of young German idealists, students who had dared to speak out against the Nazis, were executed by the regime they had defied. Like a flickering flame in the darkness, the White Rose, as its members called themselves, is an inspiring group that never lost its courage — and a frightening reminder of how rare such heroes are.

The group’s founder, Hans Scholl, and his sister Sophie grew up outside Munich. Their father instilled in them a strong moral compass and a religious worldview. Like many his age, Hans joined the Hitler Youth. But he began to have doubts almost immediately: The Nazis did not allow him to sing certain songs, fly certain flags or read Stefan Zweig, his favorite author. He earned a spot as a flag-bearer at the annual Nuremberg Rally and returned disturbed at what he had seen.

Hans wanted to become a doctor, and when he was drafted he was posted as a medic in France. After a tour of duty, he went back to the University of Munich to continue his medical studies. Sophie soon joined him as an undergraduate. Hans read widely — Plato, Socrates, St. Augustine and Pascal — and decorated his dorm room with Modernist French art. He attracted a circle of like-minded students: Alexander Schmorell, the son of a doctor; Christoph Probst, a young father of two toddlers; and Willi Graf, a thoughtful introvert. They soon found an intellectual mentor in Kurt Huber, a professor of philosophy and ardent believer in liberal democracy.

In the summer of 1942, Hans and his friends — inspired by the sermons of the anti-Nazi bishop of Münster — began to distribute typewritten leaflets denouncing the regime. Their language was incandescent. “Every honest German today is ashamed of his government,” Hans wrote, a government that committed “the most horrible of crimes — crimes that indefinitely outdistance every human measure.” The members of the White Rose declared that all those who stood by were complicit and implored all citizens to engage in “passive resistance” to the Nazi state.

The White Rose also addressed the atrocities against Jews. Schmorell and Hans wrote in the group’s second leaflet: “Here we see the most frightful crime against human dignity, a crime that is unparalleled in the whole of history. For Jews, too, are human beings.” No punches were pulled even when it came to the Führer: “Every word that comes from Hitler’s mouth is a lie.” Sprinkled with erudite references to Goethe, Aristotle, Schiller, Ecclesiastes, Lao Tzu and others, the leaflets concluded with a plea to support the White Rose by circulating them. “We will not be silent,” ended the fourth. “We are your bad conscience. The White Rose will not leave you in peace.”

The leaflets appeared in mailboxes and phone booths between late June and mid-July 1942 and spread to sympathetic students in Frankfurt, Hamburg, Berlin and Vienna. Then they stopped as Hans, Schmorell, Graf and Probst were shipped east on a day’s notice to the Russian front, where the Germans were bogged down. Yet Hans fought back against the Nazis with acts of simple humanity even as he approached the front. On his train to Russia, he saw a young Jewish girl doing hard labor, wearing the yellow Star of David mandated by the Nazis. Running from his transport, Hans handed her a chocolate bar from his rations — and a daisy for her hair.

After returning from the front, Hans and the others released two more leaflets warning that with the loss at Stalingrad, German defeat was inevitable. Declaring the preciousness of individual rights, the leaflets asked, “Are we forever to be a nation that is hated and rejected by all mankind?” Hans, Schmorell and Graf sneaked out at night and painted signs reading “Down with Hitler,” “Freedom” and other slogans on the main boulevard in Munich.

Then on Feb. 18, 1943, Hans and Sophie decided to distribute leaflets at the university, leaving stacks in corridors. As they started to leave, Sophie noticed that there were more copies in their suitcase and headed to the top of the stairs, which overlooked an atrium. She hurled the remaining leaflets in the air and watched as they drifted down the stairwell.

The maintenance man, Jakob Schmid, an ardent Nazi, was watching. He immediately locked the doors and notified the authorities. The siblings were hauled to the Wittelsbach Palace, the headquarters of the Gestapo. Soon after, Probst, whose wife had had a third child weeks before, was also arrested. The three were interrogated for several days, but they refused to implicate others.

All three were found of guilty of high treason and sentenced to death. Within hours, they were executed by guillotine. Before Hans placed his head upon the block, his final words echoed through the prison: “Long live freedom.” Within weeks, the other core members of the White Rose were apprehended and executed.

The story of the White Rose did make it to the front, where it inspired soldiers who were opposed to the regime. But the hope that its members had of inspiring their fellow citizens was not fulfilled. Their call was ignored.

“They did not seek martyrdom in the name of any extraordinary idea,” Inge Scholl recalled in her memoir of her siblings and White Rose comrades. “They wanted to make it possible for people like you and me to live in a humane society.” We are far from the darkness of fascism, but we do ourselves a service by remembering the sad but noble story of these beautiful souls on the anniversary of their tragic sacrifice.


quarta-feira, 21 de fevereiro de 2018

As Mulheres de Eduardo Galeano - "Tituba"


Tinha sido caçada na América do Sul logo à infância, e tinha sido vendida uma vez e outra e mais outra, e passando de dono em dono viera parar à vila de Salem, na América do Norte.

Ali, nesse santuário puritano, a escrava Tituba servia em casa do reverendo Samuel Parris.

As filhas do reverendo adoravam-na. Sonhavam acordadas quando Tituba lhes contava histórias de aparições ou lhes lia o futuro numa clara de ovo. E no inverno de 1692, quando as meninas foram possuídas por Satã e se contorciam e guinchavam, só Tituba conseguiu acalmá-las, acariciando-as e sussurrando-lhes histórias até que as adormeceu no seu regaço.

Isso condenou-a: fora ela trazer o Inferno para o virtuoso reino dos eleitos de Deus.

E a maga-contos foi amarrada ao cadafalso na praça pública e confessou.

Acusaram-na de cozinhar pastéis com receitas diabólicas e açoitaram-na até ela dizer que sim.

Acusaram-na de dançar nua nos concílios de bruxas e açoitaram-na até ela dizer que sim.

Acusaram-na de dormir com Satã e açoitaram-na até ela dizer que sim.

E quando lhe disseram que tinha por cúmplices duas velhas que nunca iam à igreja, a acusada converteu-se em acusadora e apontou o dedo a esse par de endemoninhadas e já não foi açoitada.

E depois outras acusadas acusaram.

E a forca não deixou de trabalhar.

Eduardo Galeano

"Documenting the Rohingya refugee crisis – in pictures" - Kevin Frayer


More than half a million Rohingya refugees have flooded into Bangladesh to flee an offensive by Myanmar’s military which the United Nations has called ‘a textbook example of ethnic cleansing’.

Disco recomendado - "Tribalistas" 2017




Tribalistas

Hoje é dia de Malcolm X




Malcolm X

terça-feira, 20 de fevereiro de 2018

As Mulheres de Eduardo Galeano - "Xerazade"



Para se vingar de uma, que o atraiçoara, o rei degolava todas.
Casava-se ao crepúsculo e ao amanhecer enviuva.
Uma após outra, as virgens perdiam a virgindade e a cabeça.
Xerazade foi a única que sobreviveu à primeira noite, e depois continuou a trocar um conto por cada novo dia de vida.
Estas histórias, por ela escutadas, lidas ou inventadas, salvaram-na da decapitação. Contava-as em voz baixa, na penumbra da alcova, sem outra luz que não a da lua. Sentia prazer ao contá-las, e prazer oferecia, mas tinha muito cuidado. Às vezes, enquanto narrava, sentia que o rei estava a estudar-lhe o pescoço.
Se o rei se aborrecesse, ela estava perdida.
Foi do medo de morrer que nasceu a mestria de narrar.

Portugal na imprensa estrangeira - "22 reasons why everyone is going to Portugal right now"


Everyone seems to be going to Portugal right now. Indeed, this week the country reported gleefully on another record year for overseas arrivals. Just over 12.7 million foreigners visited the country in 2017 – up 12 per cent year-on-year. Here's why it is proving so popular.

Hoje é dia de Kurt Cobain




Kurt Cobain

Nirvana

"The Dangers of Militarization" - Javier Solana


A great-power conflict is in no way unavoidable, unless these powers act as if it were. The greatest risk is that the US forgets the principles and institutions that have shored up its global leadership and, by emphasizing a narrative of confrontation, exposes the world to a self-fulfilling prophecy.

segunda-feira, 19 de fevereiro de 2018

Hoje é dia de André Breton




André Breton

"The Seven Deadly Sins of AI Predictions" - Rodney Brooks


We are surrounded by hysteria about the future of artificial intelligence and robotics—hysteria about how powerful they will become, how quickly, and what they will do to jobs.
I recently saw a story in ­MarketWatch that said robots will take half of today’s jobs in 10 to 20 years. It even had a graphic to prove the numbers.

The claims are ludicrous. (I try to maintain professional language, but sometimes …) For instance, the story appears to say that we will go from one million grounds and maintenance workers in the U.S. to only 50,000 in 10 to 20 years, because robots will take over those jobs. How many robots are currently operational in those jobs? Zero. How many realistic demonstrations have there been of robots working in this arena? Zero. Similar stories apply to all the other categories where it is suggested that we will see the end of more than 90 percent of jobs that currently require physical presence at some particular site.

Mistaken predictions lead to fears of things that are not going to happen, whether it’s the wide-scale destruction of jobs, the Singularity, or the advent of AI that has values different from ours and might try to destroy us. We need to push back on these mistakes. But why are people making them? I see seven common reasons.

1. Overestimating and underestimating

Roy Amara was a cofounder of the Institute for the Future, in Palo Alto, the intellectual heart of Silicon Valley. He is best known for his adage now referred to as Amara’s Law:

We tend to overestimate the effect of a technology in the short run and underestimate the effect in the long run.

There is a lot wrapped up in these 21 words. An optimist can read it one way, and a pessimist can read it another.

A great example of the two sides of Amara’s Law is the U.S. Global Positioning System. Starting in 1978, a constellation of 24 satellites (now 31 including spares) were placed in orbit. The goal of GPS was to allow precise delivery of munitions by the U.S. military. But the program was nearly canceled again and again in the 1980s. The first operational use for its intended purpose was in 1991 during Desert Storm; it took several more successes for the military to accept its utility.

Today GPS is in what Amara would call the long term, and the ways it is used were unimagined at first. My Series 2 Apple Watch uses GPS while I am out running, recording my location accurately enough to see which side of the street I run along. The tiny size and price of the receiver would have been incomprehensible to the early GPS engineers. The technology synchronizes physics experiments across the globe and plays an intimate role in synchronizing the U.S. electrical grid and keeping it running. It even allows the high-frequency traders who really control the stock market to mostly avoid disastrous timing errors. It is used by all our airplanes, large and small, to navigate, and it is used to track people out of prison on parole. It determines which seed variant will be planted in which part of many fields across the globe. It tracks fleets of trucks and reports on driver ­performance.

GPS started out with one goal, but it was a hard slog to get it working as well as was originally expected. Now it has seeped into so many aspects of our lives that we would not just be lost if it went away; we would be cold, hungry, and quite possibly dead.

We see a similar pattern with other technologies over the last 30 years. A big promise up front, disappointment, and then slowly growing confidence in results that exceed the original expectations. This is true of computation, genome sequencing, solar power, wind power, and even home delivery of groceries.

AI has been overestimated again and again, in the 1960s, in the 1980s, and I believe again now, but its prospects for the long term are also probably being underestimated. The question is: How long is the long term? The next six errors help explain why the time scale is being grossly underestimated for the future of AI.

2. Imagining magic

When I was a teenager, Arthur C. Clarke was one of the “big three” science fiction writers, along with Robert Heinlein and Isaac Asimov. But Clarke was also an inventor, a science writer, and a futurist. Between 1962 and 1973 he formulated three adages that have come to be known as Clarke’s Three Laws:

When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.

The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible.

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.

Personally, I should probably be wary of the second sentence in his first law, as I am much more conservative than some others about how quickly AI will be ascendant. But for now I want to expound on Clarke’s Third Law.

Imagine we had a time machine and we could transport Isaac Newton from the late 17th century to today, setting him down in a place that would be familiar to him: Trinity College Chapel at the University of Cambridge.

Now show Newton an Apple. Pull out an iPhone from your pocket, and turn it on so that the screen is glowing and full of icons, and hand it to him. Newton, who revealed how white light is made from components of different-colored light by pulling apart sunlight with a prism and then putting it back together, would no doubt be surprised at such a small object producing such vivid colors in the darkness of the chapel. Now play a movie of an English country scene, and then some church music that he would have heard. And then show him a Web page with the 500-plus pages of his personally annotated copy of his masterpiece Principia, teaching him how to use the pinch gesture to zoom in on details.

Could Newton begin to explain how this small device did all that? Although he invented calculus and explained both optics and gravity, he was never able to sort out chemistry from alchemy. So I think he would be flummoxed, and unable to come up with even the barest coherent outline of what this device was. It would be no different to him from an embodiment of the occult—something that was of great interest to him. It would be indistinguishable from magic. And remember, Newton was a really smart dude.

If something is magic, it is hard to know its limitations. Suppose we further show Newton how the device can illuminate the dark, how it can take photos and movies and record sound, how it can be used as a magnifying glass and as a mirror. Then we show him how it can be used to carry out arithmetical computations at incredible speed and to many decimal places. We show it counting the steps he has taken as he carries it, and show him that he can use it to talk to people anywhere in the world, immediately, from right there in the chapel.

What else might Newton conjecture that the device could do? Prisms work forever. Would he conjecture that the iPhone would work forever just as it is, neglecting to understand that it needs to be recharged? Recall that we nabbed him from a time 100 years before the birth of Michael Faraday, so he lacked a scientific understanding of electricity. If the iPhone can be a source of light without fire, could it perhaps also transmute lead into gold?

This is a problem we all have with imagined future technology. If it is far enough away from the technology we have and understand today, then we do not know its limitations. And if it becomes indistinguishable from magic, anything one says about it is no longer falsifiable.

This is a problem I regularly encounter when trying to debate with people about whether we should fear artificial general intelligence, or AGI—the idea that we will build autonomous agents that operate much like beings in the world. I am told that I do not understand how powerful AGI will be. That is not an argument. We have no idea whether it can even exist. I would like it to exist—this has always been my own motivation for working in robotics and AI. But modern-day AGI research is not doing well at all on either being general or supporting an independent entity with an ongoing existence. It mostly seems stuck on the same issues in reasoning and common sense that AI has had problems with for at least 50 years. All the evidence that I see says we have no real idea yet how to build one. Its properties are completely unknown, so rhetorically it quickly becomes magical, powerful without limit.

Nothing in the universe is without limit.

Watch out for arguments about future technology that is magical. Such an argument can never be refuted. It is a faith-based argument, not a scientific argument.

3. Performance versus competence

We all use cues about how people perform some particular task to estimate how well they might perform some different task. In a foreign city we ask a stranger on the street for directions, and she replies with confidence and with directions that seem to make sense, so we figure we can also ask her about the local system for paying when you want to take a bus.

Now suppose a person tells us that a particular photo shows people playing Frisbee in the park. We naturally assume that this person can answer questions like What is the shape of a Frisbee? Roughly how far can a person throw a Frisbee? Can a person eat a Frisbee? Roughly how many people play Frisbee at once? Can a three-month-old person play Frisbee? Is today’s weather suitable for playing Frisbee?

This does not mean that these systems are useless; they are of great value to search engines. But here is what goes wrong. People hear that some robot or some AI system has performed some task. They then generalize from that performance to a competence that a person performing the same task could be expected to have. And they apply that generalization to the robot or AI system.Computers that can label images like “people playing Frisbee in a park” have no chance of answering those questions. Besides the fact that they can only label more images and cannot answer questions at all, they have no idea what a person is, that parks are usually outside, that people have ages, that weather is anything more than how it makes a photo look, etc.

Today’s robots and AI systems are incredibly narrow in what they can do. Human-style generalizations do not apply.

4. Suitcase words

Marvin Minsky called words that carry a variety of meanings “suitcase words.” “Learning” is a powerful suitcase word; it can refer to so many different types of experience. Learning to use chopsticks is a very different experience from learning the tune of a new song. And learning to write code is a very different experience from learning your way around a city.

When people hear that machine learning is making great strides in some new domain, they tend to use as a mental model the way in which a person would learn that new domain. However, machine learning is very brittle, and it requires lots of preparation by human researchers or engineers, special-purpose coding, special-purpose sets of training data, and a custom learning structure for each new problem domain. Today’s machine learning is not at all the sponge-like learning that humans engage in, making rapid progress in a new domain without having to be surgically altered or purpose-built.

Likewise, when people hear that a computer can beat the world chess champion (in 1997) or one of the world’s best Go players (in 2016), they tend to think that it is “playing” the game just as a human would. Of course, in reality those programs had no idea what a game actually was, or even that they were playing. They were also much less adaptable. When humans play a game, a small change in rules does not throw them off. Not so for AlphaGo or Deep Blue.

Suitcase words mislead people about how well machines are doing at tasks that people can do. That is partly because AI researchers—and, worse, their institutional press offices—are eager to claim progress in an instance of a suitcase concept. The important phrase here is “an instance.” That detail soon gets lost. Headlines trumpet the suitcase word, and warp the general understanding of where AI is and how close it is to accomplishing more.

5. Exponentials

Many people are suffering from a severe case of “exponentialism.”

Everyone has some idea about Moore’s Law, which suggests that computers get better and better on a clockwork-like schedule. What Gordon Moore actually said was that the number of components that could fit on a microchip would double every year. That held true for 50 years, although the time constant for doubling gradually lengthened from one year to over two years, and the pattern is coming to an end.

Doubling the components on a chip has made computers continually double in speed. And it has led to memory chips that quadruple in capacity every two years. It has also led to digital cameras that have better and better resolution, and LCD screens with exponentially more pixels.

The reason Moore’s Law worked is that it applied to a digital abstraction of a true-or-false question. In any given circuit, is there an electrical charge or voltage there or not? The answer remains clear as chip components get smaller and smaller—until a physical limit intervenes, and we get down to components with so few electrons that quantum effects start to dominate. That is where we are now with our silicon-based chip technology.

When people are suffering from exponentialism, they may think that the exponentials they use to justify an argument are going to continue apace. But Moore’s Law and other seemingly exponential laws can fail because they were not truly exponential in the first place.

Back in the first part of this century, when I was running MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL) and needed to help raise money for over 90 different research groups, I tried to use the memory increase on iPods to show sponsors how things were continuing to change very rapidly. Here are the data on how much music storage one got in an iPod for $400 or less:

year
gigabytes
2002 10
2003 20
2004 40
2006 80
2007 160

Then I would extrapolate a few years out and ask what we would do with all that memory in our pockets.

Extrapolating through to today, we would expect a $400 iPod to have 160,000 gigabytes of memory. But the top iPhone of today (which costs much more than $400) has only 256 gigabytes of memory, less than double the capacity of the 2007 iPod. This particular exponential collapsed very suddenly once the amount of memory got to the point where it was big enough to hold any reasonable person’s music library and apps, photos, and videos. Exponentials can collapse when a physical limit is hit, or when there is no more economic rationale to continue them.

Similarly, we have seen a sudden increase in performance of AI systems thanks to the success of deep learning. Many people seem to think that means we will continue to see AI performance increase by equal multiples on a regular basis. But the deep-learning success was 30 years in the making, and it was an isolated event.

That does not mean there will not be more isolated events, where work from the backwaters of AI research suddenly fuels a rapid-step increase in the performance of many AI applications. But there is no “law” that says how often they will happen.



6. Hollywood scenarios

The plot for many Hollywood science fiction movies is that the world is just as it is today, except for one new twist.

In Bicentennial Man, Richard Martin, played by Sam Neill, sits down to breakfast and is waited upon by a walking, talking humanoid robot, played by Robin Williams. Richard picks up a newspaper to read over breakfast. A newspaper! Printed on paper. Not a tablet computer, not a podcast coming from an Amazon Echo–like device, not a direct neural connection to the Internet.

It turns out that many AI researchers and AI pundits, especially those pessimists who indulge in predictions about AI getting out of control and killing people, are similarly imagination-challenged. They ignore the fact that if we are able to eventually build such smart devices, the world will have changed significantly by then. We will not suddenly be surprised by the existence of such super-intelligences. They will evolve technologically over time, and our world will come to be populated by many other intelligences, and we will have lots of experience already. Long before there are evil super-intelligences that want to get rid of us, there will be somewhat less intelligent, less belligerent machines. Before that, there will be really grumpy machines. Before that, quite annoying machines. And before them, arrogant, unpleasant machines. We will change our world along the way, adjusting both the environment for new technologies and the new technologies themselves. I am not saying there may not be challenges. I am saying that they will not be sudden and unexpected, as many people think.

7. Speed of deployment

New versions of software are deployed very frequently in some industries. New features for platforms like Facebook are deployed almost hourly. For many new features, as long as they have passed integration testing, there is very little economic downside if a problem shows up in the field and the version needs to be pulled back. This is a tempo that Silicon Valley and Web software developers have gotten used to. It works because the marginal cost of newly deploying code is very, very close to zero.

Deploying new hardware, on the other hand, has significant marginal costs. We know that from our own lives. Many of the cars we are buying today, which are not self-driving, and mostly are not ­software-enabled, will probably still be on the road in the year 2040. This puts an inherent limit on how soon all our cars will be self-driving. If we build a new home today, we can expect that it might be around for over 100 years. The building I live in was built in 1904, and it is not nearly the oldest in my neighborhood.

Capital costs keep physical hardware around for a long time, even when there are high-tech aspects to it, and even when it has an existential mission.

The U.S. Air Force still flies the B-52H variant of the B-52 bomber. This version was introduced in 1961, making it 56 years old. The last one was built in 1962, a mere 55 years ago. Currently these planes are expected to keep flying until at least 2040, and perhaps longer—there is talk of extending their life to 100 years.

I regularly see decades-old equipment in factories around the world. I even see PCs running Windows 3.0—a software version released in 1990. The thinking is “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” Those PCs and their software have been running the same application doing the same task reliably for over two decades.

The principal control mechanism in factories, including brand-new ones in the U.S., Europe, Japan, Korea, and China, is based on programmable logic controllers, or PLCs. These were introduced in 1968 to replace electromechanical relays. The “coil” is still the principal abstraction unit used today, and PLCs are programmed as though they were a network of 24-volt electromechanical relays. Still. Some of the direct wires have been replaced by Ethernet cables. But they are not part of an open network. Instead they are individual cables, run point to point, physically embodying the control flow—the order in which steps get executed—in these brand-new ancient automation controllers. When you want to change information flow, or control flow, in most factories around the world, it takes weeks of consultants figuring out what is there, designing new reconfigurations, and then teams of tradespeople to rewire and reconfigure hardware. One of the major manufacturers of this equipment recently told me that they aim for three software upgrades every 20 years.

In principle, it could be done differently. In practice, it is not. I just looked on a jobs list, and even today, this very day, Tesla Motors is trying to hire PLC technicians at its factory in Fremont, California. They will use electromagnetic relay emulation in the production of the most AI-enhanced automobile that exists.

A lot of AI researchers and pundits imagine that the world is already digital, and that simply introducing new AI systems will immediately trickle down to operational changes in the field, in the supply chain, on the factory floor, in the design of products.

Nothing could be further from the truth. Almost all innovations in robotics and AI take far, far, longer to be really widely deployed than people in the field and outside the field imagine.

Rodney Brooks is a former director of the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory at MIT and a founder of Rethink Robotics and iRobot.

"America First — Or Against All?" - Jean-François Boittin


To Trump, everything in politics – even at the global trade stage – is about him personally and how it affects his business interests.

domingo, 18 de fevereiro de 2018

Filme recomendado - "The Post"



Realização de Steven Spielberg

"A Divided Germany Came Together for the Olympics Decades Before Korea Did - Erin Blakemore


At the opening ceremonies of the XXIII Olympic Winter Games, on February 9, 2018, something spectacular happened: Athletes from North and South Korea, which have been bitterly divided for 73 years, marched beneath a unified flag. Though North and South appear no closer to reunification, the move was seen as an olive branch of sorts that could pave the way for better relations between the estranged countries—and it’s just one example of how the worldwide sporting event can bring people together, if only for a few weeks.

"Misery for Women and Girls in Greece’s Island Paradise" - Hillary Margolis


Government Downplays Sexual Violence Risks in Migrant Hotspots

quinta-feira, 15 de fevereiro de 2018

"CARTA ABERTA POR UMA GESTÃO PÚBLICA DO TEATRO MARIA MATOS"


A 17 de Dezembro de 2017, a Vereadora da Cultura da Câmara Municipal de Lisboa, (CML), Catarina Vaz Pinto, anunciou numa entrevista ao jornal Público que a saída do director artístico do Teatro Maria Matos (TMM), Mark Deputter, para a Culturgest e o encerramento do Teatro da Cornucópia – sedeado no espaço alugado do Teatro do Bairro Alto (TBA) – levaram a autarquia a repensar a rede de teatros municipais. Na mesma entrevista afirmou que a CML irá entregar a gestão do TMM, espaço que lhe pertence, a uma entidade privada, e que este passará a ter “um modelo de programação bastante diferente, com carreiras mais longas e uma maior preocupação de captação de público, para ser rentável”. Anunciou ainda que a CML se responsabiliza por dois novos teatros: o TBA, agora alugado e gerido pela CML, vocacionado “para o teatro e as artes performativas contemporâneas emergentes”; e o Teatro Luís de Camões (TLC), recém-reabilitado pela CML, para a programação infanto-juvenil.

Desde esse anúncio, foi criada uma petição pela gestão pública do Teatro Maria Matos, que reuniu mais de 2750 assinaturas e que foi entregue à Assembleia Municipal.

A forma como esta decisão foi tomada e anunciada, sem debate prévio, demonstrou desrespeito pelos cidadãos e por um processo democrático que, como a CML tanto tem vindo a afirmar, se quer participado. Tal foi passível de ser comprovado - não obstante a disponibilidade sem precedentes da Sra. Vereadora da Cultura para participar num debate organizado pelos peticionários no dia 14 de Fevereiro - pelo facto de este ter tido lugar dois dias antes da reunião de Câmara, onde será votado um documento que elenca linhas orientadoras relativas à programação artística do Teatro Maria Matos, i. e, quando as decisões finais parecem já estar tomadas. Do mesmo modo, a forma como nas suas intervenções os factos e perguntas concretas dos presentes foram reduzidos a “mera emoção” e descartados sem direito efectivo a resposta clara, minou a possibilidade de uma real conversa transformando-a numa encenação de democraticidade. Nós, enquanto público e artistas, produtores e programadores, críticos e investigadores, temos uma opinião, feita de emoção e de razão. Vivemos na cidade, e frequentamos os lugares; temos pensamento sobre o papel da autarquia na definição da política de cultura de Lisboa, e acreditamos que só com a multiplicidade de todas as vozes na definição desta mesma política conseguiremos uma cidade mais democrática.

Assim, e no seguimento deste processo, vimos com esta Carta Aberta, documento de trabalho colectivamente redigido:

I. Clarificar a opinião pública sobre um conjunto de pontos a nosso ver essenciais para a correcta avaliação do que está em causa nesta decisão; 

II. Solicitar o esclarecimento por parte da vereadora de uma série de questões fundamentais para a boa compreensão da sua decisão, com a qual não concordamos, e que, na ausência destes esclarecimentos, nos parece pouco transparente.

Se na secção (I) procuramos responder a discussões travadas na esfera pública ensaiando, sempre que possível, clarificar factos, na secção (II) sublinhamos a insuficiência de dados facultados pela CML em relação aos custos previstos inerentes à operação proposta, insistindo na necessidade de conhecimento de valores concretos e na maior transparência da CML.


I. Clarificações

No debate do dia 14 de Fevereiro, a Vereadora da Cultura repetiu várias vezes, que o actual projecto do Teatro Maria Matos acaba aqui como consequência da saída do seu director artístico. Isto não é evidente para nós. A saída do director artístico é uma coisa natural. Defender que a missão de determinado espaço cultural municipal não sobrevive à saída de um director artístico já não é natural e mostra uma falta de sentido de responsabilidade em relação ao investimento que se fez, em dinheiro e conhecimento técnico, na construção desta missão. No ecossistema cultural da cidade de Lisboa - com o qual a Vereadora da Cultura se preocupa, como deve - o Teatro Maria Matos não é apenas um espaço para a apresentação de criação artística contemporânea / experimental / emergente. Isto é feito em vários outros espaços na cidade, dos quais o Teatro Maria Matos se distingue por ser o único a assumir um posicionamento político (não partidário) e a convidar-nos para pensarmos o nosso mundo e a forma como vamos viver em conjunto. Acreditamos que cabe à CML ser a garantia da orientação/missão do Teatro Maria Matos, por ser única na cidade e porque se tornou indispensável para muitos cidadãos. Portanto, longe de lamentarmos o fim de um projecto, esperamos que lhe seja dada continuidade, ansiosos para ver de que forma um novo director artístico enfrentará o desafio de pensar connosco a forma como vamos viver em conjunto.

1. Uma comunidade e não um público-alvo.k
O TMM excedeu a vocação de relação programação/público e passou a desempenhar também o papel crucial de ponto de encontro, entre crítica e pensamento, na qual os espectadores se tornaram participantes activos. Para tal, colaboram vários factores que vão muito além do projecto curatorial ali levado a cabo. Articulando uma relação arquitectónica singular entre a sala de espectáculos, o foyer e o bar-lugar-de-encontro-janela-para-a-rua - com uma escala que permitiu que fosse apropriada por moradores, artistas, e frequentadores quaisquer; e tornando porosas as suas fronteiras à cidade e à formação de comunidade - o TMM criou a potência de encontro, capaz de alterar as condições de possibilidade do próprio lugar. O TMM deixou pois de ser “só um teatro” e passou para o domínio público. Os grupos que aqui se juntaram reivindicam este com-domínio para uso público. As decisões sobre o destino deste espaço devem ter em conta o que aqui se criou, o uso do espaço físico e geográfico, as práticas que cresceram neste espaço concreto e que não são linearmente transportáveis para outro lugar. A mudança anunciada resultará num desmantelamento. Trabalhar com condições e sinergias activas é diferente de começar tudo de novo. Há vozes que desejam ter lugar, desejam poder continuar a discutir os lugares públicos. Que este acontecimento o tenha tornado visível a partir de um teatro é já de si uma vitória.

2. Um dos argumentos levantados pela Vereadora da Cultura foi a desadequação do espaço do TMM à programação que tem acolhido, expressada por em quase toda a sua programação se ter colocado uma bancada amovível no palco para assegurar uma relação menos distante entre público e artistas. A realidade é diferente: entre Junho de 2009 e Junho de 2017, o TMM apresentou cerca de 140 espectáculos de teatro/dança com bancada amovível (de 180 pessoas) e 90 espectáculos usando toda a capacidade da sala; e cerca de 40 concertos com bancada e 95 concertos usando toda a sala. Ou seja, só contando com a programação de teatro houve uma relação 60/40 com/sem bancada amovível. Contando com toda a programação a relação é 50/50. Nesta argumentação da Vereadora, a utilização da bancada amovível é encarada apenas como característica fragilizadora do espaço MM. A sua mais-valia enquanto dispositivo de flexibilização do espaço capaz de apoiar a afirmação e crescimento gradual de projectos artísticos, simultânea à formação e crescimento de públicos não é reconhecida. Foram vários os projectos artísticos que começaram por se apresentar com a bancada amovível e passaram, mais tarde, a apresentar-se usando a sala completa, nomeadamente: a Mala Voadora, Joana Sá ou Raquel Castro.

3. Um outro argumento levantado foi a falta de público para encher a sala, reforçada pela descida dos números nos últimos anos, o que obriga a CML a repensar o TMM, como espaço, e a sua programação. Os números dos últimos anos são os que se seguem e revelam a fragilidade deste argumento:

Ano : Público
2010: 23 519
2011: 22 593
2012: 21 889
2013: 32 402
2014: 36 654
2015: 31 139
2016: 24 329
2017: 34 662

Ao mesmo tempo, acreditamos que os números de público não podem ser a medida da qualidade dos espectáculos e, como tal, não devem servir de pretexto nem à entrega de um equipamento municipal à gestão privada, nem a uma alteração profunda da sua missão artística.

4. Foi defendido pela Vereadora da Cultura que a programação do TMM poderia passar, com vantagem, para dois outros teatros (TBA e TLC). Temos as maiores dúvidas sobre isso. A separação e desmembramento das várias dimensões da missão de um espaço cultural resulta na perda de consistência e sentido. Esta decisão reforça a concentração da produção artística experimental “contemporânea” no eixo central Cais do Sodré - Bairro Alto - Rato, contribuindo para espartilhar geograficamente e dividir em segmentos de consumo, sem contacto entre si, a fruição cultural da cidade. Vem também despojar o eixo norte-nascente de Lisboa do único equipamento cultural municipal dedicado às artes performativas. Finalmente, apesar da dita “desadequação” do espaço do TMM à produção artística contemporânea, há espectáculos que nele têm tido lugar e que dificilmente poderão ter lugar no TBA: por um lado, uma vez que este se insere num espaço residencial, não houve garantias da existência de condições de isolamento acústico exigido, por exemplo, no caso de alguns concertos (parte importante da actual programação do MM); por outro, uma vez que a Vereadora também não garantiu que o TBA venha a ter as condições técnicas necessárias à realização de espectáculos de média escala com maior exigência do ponto de vista técnico.

5. Por que razão dois por um e não um mais dois? No que diz respeito a uma eventual incapacidade da CML de manter a gestão do TMM, ao mesmo tempo que a dos dois novos espaços referidos (TBA e TLC), afirmada pela Vereadora da Cultura em reunião, o programador António Pinto Ribeiro foi muito claro no seu artigo de opinião (Público, 16.12.2018): “No contexto financeiro actual, nada obstaria a que a CML não pudesse manter o Maria Matos, o Teatro Luís de Camões e o Teatro do Bairro Alto — como unidade de produção experimental —, desde que essa indicação fosse dada como uma prioridade na gestão da Empresa de Gestão de Equipamentos e Animação Cultural (EGEAC).

6. Por que razão não deve um teatro municipal ter gestão privada, de vocação comercial? A programação comercial, pela sua natureza e fins maioritariamente lucrativos, é vocação de privados que devem investir, arriscar, beneficiar de lucros no quadro legal, em concorrência. A CML, ao entrar nesta lógica comercial, está a fomentar competição desleal no mercado do teatro comercial permitindo ao futuro concessionário competir em desigualdade com outros privados, uma vez que beneficiará de recursos excepcionais (pagos pelos nossos impostos durante anos). O dever da CML é assegurar que a arte seja o mais possível acessível a todos, quer do lado da criação quer do lado da fruição e não pode colocar em causa princípios como a boa gestão de dinheiros públicos. De acordo com os relatórios da EGEAC, ao longo dos últimos 8 anos, terá sido feito um investimento de 92.939 euros em melhorias estruturais e equipamentos. Foi igualmente feito um investimento de 16.000 euros num novo website. A Vereadora da Cultura afirmou na reunião de dia 14 de Feveriero algo mais preocupante: o investimento financeiro em equipamento técnico do MM será igualmente cedido ao futuro concessionário privado do espaço. Parece, pois, que neste caso concreto o investimento feito com capitais públicos vai servir a entidade privada que vier gerir o TMM.


II. Dúvidas

A forma infeliz em que foi anunciada a decisão da atribuição da gestão do TMM a privados faz ressaltar o que parece ser uma marca do executivo de Fernando Medina: o desenho top-down da cidade sem que os seus habitantes sejam tidos em conta. Esta tem vindo a ser observada no incentivo camarário à financeirização do solo urbano, cujo aspecto mais visível é o crescente número de autorizações concedidas a equipamentos vocacionados para o turismo, e, o menos visível, a vaga de despejos de lojas, habitações e instituições culturais, algumas delas com mais de um século de existência. Sendo inegável o momento de transformação que Lisboa actualmente atravessa e o papel da CML neste desenho – e, dentro deste, o papel esperado da cultura e da EGEAC nesse processo – vimos assim solicitar a disponibilização pública dos dados concretos que a este caso dizem respeito, para que cidadãs e cidadãos possam compreender e validar a justeza de tais decisões.

1. Custos

1.1 Receitas:

- Qual a receita prevista com a privatização da gestão do TMM, i.e, por que valor mensal se conta concessionar o equipamento?

- Qual a figura jurídica sob a qual se processará esta concessão e mediante que condições?

1.2. Despesas:

- De acordo com os relatórios da EGEAC ao longo dos últimos 8 anos terá sido feito um investimento de 92.939 euros em melhorias estruturais e equipamentos imobilizados. Foi igualmente feito um investimento de 16 mil euros num novo website. O investimento na reabilitação do edifício beneficiará sempre a entidade privada que o vier concessionar. A vereadora afirmou na reunião de dia 14 algo mais preocupante, o investimento financeiro em equipamento técnico imobilizado do MM será igualmente cedido ao futuro concessionário privado do espaço. Há alguma parte destes investimentos feitos com capital público que, com esta decisão, não passarão para as mãos da entidade privada que vier gerir o teatro?

- Quais os custos do aluguer e despesas correntes da sala do TBA?

- Quanto está previsto custarem as obras a serem feitas neste equipamento (TBA), quais serão, e como será atribuída a sua concessão?

- Quanto está previsto gastar-se e como se procederá na compra de equipamento para o TBA?

- Quanto foi gasto na recuperação do Teatro Luiz de Camões?

- Quanto se conta gastar na manutenção da equipa dos novos equipamentos?

- Qual o balanço esperado das receitas e despesas?

2. Outros

2.1. Relação com a cidade e suas freguesias

- Num momento em que a grande maioria da população jovem Lisboeta tem vindo a abandonar o centro da cidade devido aos elevados preços da habitação, acabar com a oferta cultural experimental e de média dimensão na zona norte da cidade parece ser um contrassenso, uma decisão que contribui para o desequilíbrio territorial em curso.

Por que razão concentrar tudo numa área específica da cidade, eixo Cais do Sodré- Bairro Alto – Rato? 

- Tendo sido afirmado pela Vereadora da Cultura que neste momento está a repensar toda a rede de equipamentos culturais municipais de Lisboa, cumpre-nos perguntar quais os planos, a nível cultural, para as freguesias de Alvalade, Areeiro, Lumiar, Benfica e Marvila?

- O que vai acontecer às parcerias estabelecidas com redes internacionais, uma parte significativa do orçamento para a programação do TMM, e que se têm revelado essenciais na afirmação da cidade num tecido de artes performativas global?

- Havendo já o Tivoli, o Capitólio (e futuramente o Teatro Variedades), o Mundial, o S. Jorge, o Coliseu, e dezenas de outras salas, por que razão precisa a cidade de mais um teatro vocacionado para o teatro comercial?

2.2. Garantias e salvaguardas se a decisão de cedência da gestão do TMM a privados se efectivar.

Não concordando com a cedência da gestão do TMM a privados, gostaríamos de saber quais as garantias ou salvaguardas que a CML irá exigir aos futuros concorrentes:

- A CML terá a capacidade para definir um preço máximo de entrada e com isso manter a acessibilidade aos espectáculos da maior parte da população, independentemente do seu rendimento?

- A CML será capaz de garantir um conjunto de descontos, como o que acontece com outros equipamentos (ex. reformados, desempregados, estudantes, pessoas com deficiência, entre outros)?

- Quem fará a avaliação das propostas? Serão as mesmas alvo de discussão pública?

- Como será feita a avaliação durante o período de concessão?

- Que garantias tem a CML que as obrigações serão cumpridas pelo privado?

- Imaginemos que por alguma razão o privado incumpre o contrato, como será ressarcida a CML pelo incumprimento do mesmo?

- Há algum documento produzido? Onde se pode consultar?

O público esclarecimento destas questões pode não apenas ajudar a compreender o que está em causa nesta proposta como contribuir para o cumprimento de políticas culturais municipais mais democráticas, transparentes e participadas.

Livro recomendado - "Para onde vão os gatos quando morrem?"


Luís Cardoso

"Don’t look to Trump for leadership after the Florida school shooting" - Richard Wolffe


They say there’s no one more optimistic than an American teenager. But now we’re teaching them how to save their lives from a gunman

terça-feira, 13 de fevereiro de 2018

Hoje é dia de Agostinho da Silva


"Galileo in Rome for Inquisition"


On this day in 1633, Italian philosopher, astronomer and mathematician Galileo Galilei arrives in Rometo face charges of heresy for advocating Copernican theory, which holds that the Earth revolves around the Sun. Galileo officially faced the Roman Inquisition in April of that same year and agreed to plead guilty in exchange for a lighter sentence. Put under house arrest indefinitely by Pope Urban VIII, Galileo spent the rest of his days at his villa in Arcetri, near Florence, before dying on January 8, 1642.

Galileo, the son of a musician, was born February 15, 1564, in Pisa, Italy. He entered the University of Pisa planning to study medicine, but shifted his focus to philosophy and mathematics. In 1589, he became a professor at Pisa for several years, during which time he demonstrated that the speed of a falling object is not proportional to its weight, as Aristotle had believed. According to some reports, Galileo conducted his research by dropping objects of different weights from the Leaning Tower of Pisa. From 1592 to 1630, Galileo was a math professor at the University of Padua, where he developed a telescope that enabled him to observe lunar mountains and craters, the four largest satellites of Jupiter and the phases of Jupiter. He also discovered that the Milky Way was made up of stars. Following the publication of his research in 1610, Galileo gained acclaim and was appointed court mathematician at Florence.

Galileo’s research led him to become an advocate of the work of the Polish astronomer Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1573). However, the Copernican theory of a sun-centered solar system conflicted with the teachings of the powerful Roman Catholic Church, which essentially ruled Italy at the time. Church teachings contended that Earth, not the sun, was at the center of the universe. In 1633, Galileo was brought before the Roman Inquisition, a judicial system established by the papacy in 1542 to regulate church doctrine. This included the banning of books that conflicted with church teachings. The Roman Inquisition had its roots in the Inquisition of the Middle Ages, the purpose of which was to seek out and prosecute heretics, considered enemies of the state.

Today, Galileo is recognized for making important contributions to the study of motion and astronomy. His work influenced later scientists such as the English mathematician and physicist Sir Isaac Newton, who developed the law of universal gravitation. In 1992, the Vatican formally acknowledged its mistake in condemning Galileo.


Galileo affair